big dissapointment (SPOILERSSSS!!!!!!)

i TOTALLY did not like BD....

its like.... we (or at least I) had higher expectations for it...


i HATED it that Edward could read Bellas mind in the end.... i thought that part wqas pretty dumb............

Ok, I agree completly. My fav part was Jacob's POV, and that ending was WAY to happily ever after for me. And, come on NO BATTLE. I am dissapointed, but on a whole, i would still give it a 6.5-7

i LOVED the part when he was able to read her mind!

i thought it was SO sweet.

I did not. I thought that it kind of ruined the whole mystery around her. That was the mystery that puzzled him, ad now it is no longer there.

i thought it was cute because he was finally able to see how much she adores him. even though he got this glimpse, which she controlled what he saw, i don't think he will be able to see into her mind the way he does for others. there is still mystery there.

Plus, you're supposed to be able to understand someone more once you marry them.

But ya, I did not like BD at all. It read like fanfiction, and wasn't as good as any of the others. Since when does SM believe in happily ever after? She screwed around with the plot and the characters so that they could all have everything they wanted - whether it was Jake getting a girl, Bella getting a baby, Edward getting Bella forever, Bella finally getting some, Charlie getting everthing explained, no one having to fight anyone, Leah not being so depressed, the wolves not getting angry about Bella being turned, Edward reading Bella's mind . . . the list goes on and on!

YES!! Thank you. It was TOO happily ever after. There were somethings that I just accepted, but most of it I was clenching my teeth at. I am also so mad that the fact that the JakeXLeah thing got distroyed. I was looking forward to that. I liked it.

I don't know . . . I didn't think Leah was good enough for Jake, you know? He deserved better. I'm not a Leah hater . . . she's just a bit too angsty for my taste. Why is Jake attracted to depressed people?

Well, I guess we thought differently there. I wanted them to get together. Once they got to know each other, they were really cute together. I thought that they could both make themselves better.